New Zealand Is Furious At Vanguard's Historical Inaccuracy

New Zealand Is Furious At Vanguard's Historical Inaccuracy
Activision

Written by 

Tom Chapman

Published 

2nd Sep 2021 16:40

Sledgehammer Games is taking the reins from Treyarch and rolling out the big guns (literally) for the next Call of Duty game. With Call of Duty: Vanguard marching toward its release date later this year, we've got our first glimpse at what's going on in this wartime epic.

Although no one in the fictionalised version of World War II is specifically named after actual heroes who fought in the conflict, several are based on real-life fighters. For example, Russian sniper Lt. Polina Petrova is based on Lyudmila Pavlichenko (the most successful female sniper of all time), and Lucas Riggs is supposedly a counterpart of New Zealand's Charles Upham. The problem is, Sledgehammer made Riggs an Australian.

What has New Zealand said about Call of Duty: Vanguard?

Considering Upham is one of the few to ever be awarded the Victoria Cross twice, it's safe to say he's something of a national treasure in New Zealand. Over 5,000 people lined the streets of Christchurch for his funeral in 1994, he had a Naval ship commissioned after him, and a bronze statue was erected in his honour. 

As reported by New Zealand outlet Newshub (via Kotaku), there are some who are less than happy with inaccurately portraying a character who is supposed to be based on Upham as Australian. "Charles Upham’s significance cannot be overstated", said Newshub. "No other combat soldier has ever been awarded two Victoria Crosses in all of history. That incredible achievement belongs to our country alone, Aotearoa New Zealand."

Further explaining why there are problems with making Riggs Australian, the site added, "It’s like turning Sir Edmund Hillary into an Australian, or Lorde, or Jonah Lomu. It’s an insult. At best, it’s ignorance; at worst, it’s a giant middle finger to us all". 

Who are the other Vanguard characters based on?

Aside from Pavlichenco and Upham, Vanguard's Sgt. Arthur Kingsley is based on Sidney Cornell (the first black man to land on D-Day), while Cpt. Wade Jackson is a hero from the Battle of Midway called Vernon Micheel. 

More than just Sledgehammer ignoring the Upham issue, the developer has actually responded to Newshub. Sledgehammer Creative Director David Swenson said: "As with all the main characters in the campaign, we drew a lot of inspiration from real-life soldiers. With Lucas Riggs, we drew a lot of that inspiration from Charles Upham, whose exploits embodied the spirit of all the Commonwealth forces serving in North Africa."

The fact that Upham is simply representing the "Commonwealth" instead of the actual country he helms from suggest it wasn't a mistake on Sledgehammer's behalf. Added to this, it doesn't sound like the Vanguard team is going to apologise any time soon. We'd guess the entire population of New Zealand currently has Call of Duty: Vanguard in its crosshairs.

 

Tom Chapman
About the author
Tom Chapman
Tom is Trending News Editor at GGRecon, with an NCTJ qualification in Broadcast Journalism and over seven years of experience writing about film, gaming, and television. With bylines at IGN, Digital Spy, Den of Geek, and more, Tom’s love of horror means he's well-versed in all things Resident Evil, with aspirations to be the next Chris Redfield.
Why trust GGRecon?

Established in 2019, we don’t just cover games - we live them. Our expert team is full of dedicated gamers, qualified journalists, and industry insiders who collectively boast decades of experience covering gaming and esports. This deep-rooted expertise allows us to provide authoritative and nuanced perspectives first-hand from a team who are playing, and researching every game covered on our website. 

Our foundation is built on a profound commitment to editorial independence, ensuring our content remains free from external influence and advertising pressures and is held to the highest level of editorial conduct, integrity, and quality. 

Every article on GGRecon comes from rigorous research, informed analysis, and a passion for gaming that resonates with our readers. We uphold these standards through a transparent editorial policy, accessible here, which governs our processes and maintains our accountability.

Trending
Warzone fans notice one game-changing equipment piece has been flushed out
Call of Duty fans cry out for Treyarch to drop Black Ops for new sub-series
Warzone Mobile could be getting a Zombies game mode later this year
Old school MW2 LMG has an 'absurd' time-to-kill in Warzone
MW3 fans flame 'pay-to-win' Killer skins that offer Double XP to party
Related Articles
MW3 Ranked's weapon test bans more guns rather than adding them
Talented Warzone squad breaks world's fastest Nuke record
Call of Duty fans crown the 'best campaign' of all time
‘Phenomenal’ Gray Zone Warfare is everything CoD dads wished for
Underrated Marksman Rifle has 'hitscan' bullet velocity in Warzone